Pending Pies

The following are pies nominated by visitors to this website.

If you're aware of an awesome pie, nominate it.

When Pie Why
26/02/16 The Gait Inn, Millington. OK, not York, but this pie is exceptional. Suetcrust pastry to die for. - Lesley Collett
13/03/13 thomas Pub I think they are the same as the HoTM but I've descovered a secret. They do the best sunday dinners and you can have the pies with the beef & lamb gravy. Its mega and I went this monday and the gravy was better than my nans. theres a lot to be said about a great pie but also the gravy, nothing worse than a great pie with rubbish gravy. Otherwise they do it with a sweet onion gravy which is nice but its the meaty gravy. Best pie meal in york :) without hesitation - Dan
07/02/12 The Blackmiths Arms Huntington Its a proper pie and it was a proper pie wedge like me mam used to make. Lush - Cathy Stevenson
04/02/12 Woodman, Bishopthorpe Because it is absolutely amazing, homemade pie - and I really like pie. I have had many pie disappointments, but not here. The house of trembling madness pies are flipping good, but really, try this. - Nicola Berry
22/09/11 The Bay Tree - Stillington Fresh handmade pastry, locally sourced ingredients, delicate seasoning, served piping hot and absolutely delicious! Yes, it is a bit over 10 miles from the minster, but do yourself a favour and make the trip. - Justin
15/09/11 Steer Inn Apparently it's got the best steak and ale. Plus the T-Bone challenge looks great; - Steve
09/05/11 The Maltings All home made pie with proper ale gravy & home made chips..!! - Shaun Collinge
06/11/10 The Crystal Palace Says they do it. 5.95. - jon
22/09/10 The Beeswing Excellent pie at The Beeswing on the Hull Road - @everythingability (via Twitter)
13/08/10 The Royal Oak They've got Henry VIII pie. - Nigel
23/02/10 Guy Fawkes Inn (again) COME BACK COME BACK! New pies! Master Pie maker..... 10/10 GUARANTEED! You wont be dissapointed! - mat
05/02/10 The Old Starr Inn Can recommend The Old Starr Inn - @SpittierRabbit (via Twitter)
01/02/10 The Crown Inn, Great Ouseburn New owners, fantastic menu, brilliant pie. It's a pie of the day on the menu so it rotates. Steak and ales great and the chicken, leek and mushroom is also pretty special. - John
22/12/09 Blacksmiths Arms, Naburn Very nice steak. Good pastry. Large portion. - Jennifer Cliff
17/12/09 Blacksmiths Arms, Naburn I liked it and the landlord sent me a bar of chocolate recently! - Andrew
11/12/09 Little Chef Apparently it's pretty good. - Heston Blumenthal
04/12/09 The Village Inn, Wilberfoss Quite a way out of York, but worth the trip!!! - Jack
01/10/09 The Yorkshire Terrier Been a few times last month. - Susan
01/10/09 The Black Bull Inn, Escrick -
01/10/09 The Ainsty, Acomb It's my local - John